Saturday, July 10, 2004

More on exit interviews, other termination nuts and bolts suggestions

Following my recent post on exit interviews, I ran across some additional useful information (for HR types more than lawyers) on exit interviews and suggestions for implementing terminations, whether voluntary or involuntary (as opposed to making involuntary termination decisions)

First,About.com's Human Resources Blog has this: "How to Improve Exit Interview Participation Rates" (by Beth N. Carvin)

Gosh, being a lawyer and not in the HR trenches, it never occurred to me when I wrote my exit interview post that employees might not want to participate, but apparently that's a significant issue.

Exit interviews are one of the best ways to get true and honest feedback from employees. The downside is that it takes time to build up a significant amount of data from exit interviews.

Increasing your participation rate, however, can help you get greater amounts of actionable information faster from your exit interviews. . .

Research shows that the average response rate for paper and pencil exit interviews is approximately 30-35 percent. This means that a company with 2000 employees and a 15 percent turnover rate would expect to receive about 100 completed exit interviews per year. At this participation level, the organization is getting exit feedback from just five percent of the total employee population.

With just a little extra effort, you should be able to double that response rate. Read more
The next item is also from About.com's Human Resources Blog: "Employment Ending Checklist"(by Susan M. Heathfield)

Employees leave your organization for good reasons and bad reasons. On the positive side, they find new opportunities, go back to school, retire or land their dream job. Less positively, they are fired for poor performance or poor attendance or experience a layoff because of a business downturn. In each instance, you need an employment termination checklist to help the employee exit process go smoothly. Read more
I would add a couple of more suggestions to her list.

First, depending on the nature and extent of the employee's use of company information systems, efforts to secure and preserve information on the employee's workstation or laptop may be in order (hard drives are cheap, and swapping one out may preserve valuable evidence with respect to an employee leaving under questionable circumstances).

Second, if the employee has signed a confidentiality and/or noncompete agreement of any kind or been exposed significantly to confidential information subject to a company confidentiality policy, a written reminder of such obligations is probably a good idea both as a preventive measure and as possible future evidence if needed.


About.com's Human Resources Blog is here with an RSS feed available or sign up for an email newsleter here.




3 Comments:

At 7/19/2004 1:59 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Only Blogger users can post?

Hard to put a real name out there, when my blog is anonymous.

So let me ask - why in the world would any employee leaving a company fill out an exit interview? Any problems that could be corrected are no longer the employee's responsibility - and in great likelihood will be written off as sour grapes.

The rest is fluff.

That said - I like the blog, work as a recruiter in St Louis,and will be lurking and reading. Keep up the good work.

 
At 7/19/2004 2:24 PM, Blogger George said...

Apologies about that inability to leave a name and email with your comment if you're not signed up with Blogger. Another Blogger shortcoming. You can always email me (see my profile, linked at the top right).

As to exit interviews, I guess there's an element of "venting" and "closure" that may motivate some to participate.

It may be possible to require completion of the exit interview for the employee to obtain some "goodie" to which they are not otherwise entitled (think creatively here). Would employees do it for an extra $50? For a $50 gift certificate that costs only $25? Would the information be worth it?

 
At 7/19/2004 3:58 PM, Blogger B. N. Carvin said...

Hi George,

This is Beth Carvin, the author of the article on exit interview participation. If you'd like a direct link to the original article, it is located here:
http://www.nobscot.com/library/how_to_improve_participation.cfm

(Along with other articles on exit interviews here:
http://www.nobscot.com/library/articles.cfm )

You are correct that the reason employees do like to participate in exit interviews is the venting and/or closure. There is a sense of this is who I am, this what I have to say and now I'm out-of-here. People really do want to help their coworkers that they are leaving behind and most also want to help their company improve.

When we first started out with WebExit, we thought subscribers might need to offer an incentive in order to get good participation rates. We found out that it's not necessary (and doesn't really help). The key to good participation is in the communication and the process flow (as outlined in the article). I'm happy to report that WebExit subscribers are averaging about 65% participation rate with some companies up as high as 89%.

I appreciate your thoughts on the legal side of exit interviews. There is a lot of risk management that can come into play with the exits.

Best Regards,

Beth N. Carvin
CEO
Nobscot Corporation
http://www.Nobscot.com

 

Post a Comment

<< Home