"HR Socialism" rebuttal

The other day, I reported on and challenged an article about HR being dominated by socialists rather than capitalists.

Catherine Collingwood has the recent HR educational and work experience I lack, enabling her to blog a rebuttal at a level I felt unqualified to provide. Like me, Catherine also found this article troubling (in her words "extremely offensive and ill-informed"). Her response,

"Human Resources Socialists? I don’t think so!" takes the Sullivan article point-by-point and pretty much destroys it.

One of my favorites:

Sullivan: I defy you to find a human resources program that focuses on improving or supporting the performance of top performers.

Collingwood: Have you ever heard of sales commissions?